Uncertainty is certain
Particularly when you’re falling for a new person, it’s hard to know exactly where you stand. Uncertainty occurs in every relationship to an extent, but in non-monogamy sometimes it’s hard to know what comes next when there’s no default script.
Uncertainty can show up in a lot of different ways:
Checking read receipts and social media.
Checking dating profile status.
Rereading old texts to look for clues.
Asking friends to decode messages.
Seeking reassurance over and over.
“Testing” the other person instead of asking directly.
Drafting messages over and over again.
Forcing a definition conversation just to end discomfort.
Pulling away or ending things preemptively to avoid waiting.
In non-monogamy, there’s often no built in “next milestone” that signals where things stand, since many non-monogamous folks step off of the relationship escalator. Additionally, when someone has multiple partners, it brings up comparison feelings, “where do I fit?” and “will I ever be a priority?” questions.
Relationship anarchy or unintentionally labeled connections can feel freeing, but still set off anxiety of uncertainty. New relationship energy (NRE) also plays a factor, since it usually happens in full view of existing partners, adding another layer of self-consciousness.
Tolerating uncertainty is a vital skill
No one enjoys feeling uncertain. But building tolerance to uncertainty is a vital skill that we all benefit from practicing. While you’re waiting to figure out where you stand with another person or relationship, practice some of these:
Catch the habit, name the worry. When you notice yourself checking or decoding messages, that’s worry looking for relief. It doesn’t change the outcome.
Name which uncertainty you feel. Is it about them, you, or the realtionship?
Expect bumpiness in the middle. Turmoil peaking at moderate closeness is a common pattern, not an indication something is wrong.
Ask yourself: Chemistry or rumination? The intensity may come from the not-knowing.
Ask instead of testing or decoding. A direct question gets you real information, while decoding gets you more material to ruminate on that may not be accurate.
Practice mindfulness while you wait.
Know your flow activities ahead of time. Aim for real absorption, not just “keeping busy.” Becoming truly absorbed in a distracting activity can help you tolerate uncertain waiting.
Remember, uncertainty is a condition of loving anyone, not a sign you’re doing it wrong!
Transcript
If you find any transcription errors, please let us know at info@multiamory.com and we will fix it ASAP.
Dedeker: I think the thing that I've learned is that uncertainty and ambiguity is a condition of loving anybody in this life. It doesn't mean that, like, you have to tolerate, you know, someone who is being wishy-washy with you or not giving you what you want or, like, is avoiding communication. It doesn't mean you just have to deal with that. But I just don't think that there's any human relationship that we can ever have that completely scrubs away any sense of uncertainty or ambiguity, even in a long-term relationship. It's like people change and we grow and life throws us curveballs. And so I do think that whether you're non-monogamous or monogamous, in this life, ultimately, we're gonna have to deal with our relationship with uncertainty.
Jase: Welcome to the Multiamory Podcast. I'm Jase.
Emily: I'm Emily.
Dedeker: And I'm Dedeker.
Emily: We believe in looking to the future of relationships, not maintaining the status quo of the past.
Dedeker: Whether you're monogamous, polyamorous, swinging, casually dating, or if you just do relationships differently, we see you and we're here for you.
Jase: On this episode of the Multiamory Podcast, we're talking about relationship uncertainty. When you're falling for someone new, you want to know where you stand. However, maybe you're in a situationship that's never been defined, or you're deep in NRE and you're spiraling over every ambiguous text. And in non-monogamy, there's no default script for what comes next. We're looking at why the in-between stage is so turbulent, why ambiguity can feel like chemistry, and how to handle the uncertainty that comes with human relationships. If you're interested in learning about our fundamental communication tools that we reference on this show, you can check out our book Multiamory: Essential Tools for Modern Relationships, which covers some of our most used communication tools for all types of relationships. You can find links to buy it at multiamory.com/book or wherever you like to buy your books.
Dedeker: All right, so I've been threatening to write this episode for a while, um, It's—
Emily: Well done. You did it.
Dedeker: Thank you. We're finally here. Don't get too excited yet. Yeah, I found there's a lot of fascinating research on this topic of uncertainty and relationship ambiguity and how to deal with it. Personally, I found it hard to write this episode and explore this topic without jumping straight into, like, I don't know, maybe some of my best Zen coping skills of, like, how do we deal with the uncertainty of life? Yeah, how do we do it?
Emily: Existential dread in general.
Dedeker: Oh, seriously? Yeah, I think that's why I put off writing this episode as well, because some of this does feel existential. We'll get more to that later. But I want to hear from the two of you. Has there been a time in your past where maybe you didn't know where you stood with somebody, or maybe it was early on in a relationship and you were slowly going crazy because of the ambiguity of that, and how that resolved for you, if it resolved?
Jase: So it makes me think of— well, first of all, this has happened many times, but there is one relationship that came to mind where it was one that was, you know, we're kind of ambiguously dating, you know, we're hanging out a lot, we have good chemistry, but there hasn't really been a, you know, define the relationship kind of talk. And this was before my non-monogamy days, before I knew about Relationship Anarchy or Polyamory or anything else. And the way it resolved was me wanting to, you know, define the relationship and pin it down and be monogamous. And she was like, nope, And then we broke up.
Dedeker: okay, how soon? How soon? Like 2 days in? 3 weeks? 3 months in? How soon?
Jase: Uh, I'd say like maybe around the 3-month mark.
Dedeker: Okay. Yeah,
Jase: 3 or 4 months, something like that.
Dedeker: So funny, I just heard an identical story from a friend of mine. Yes, yes. When he was reflecting on a past relationship and when you feel like you beefed it, and it was that same, like, really pushing that, needing to define the relationship maybe earlier than the relationship wanted to be defined, perhaps.
Jase: Yeah, and it's one of those ones where I've talked about it before where I feel like non-monogamy would have just completely changed it because it— I got the impression the thing that she didn't want was the monogamy part, not so much the hanging out with each other and being close part. So I wish I'd known that was an option, you know.
Emily: I feel like the actual definition, like defining the relationship, has not been something in my life that has been ambiguous. But rather like other factors potentially, such as I think the time most recently when I was still in this like semi-ambiguous phase with my current partner, when, you know, he was entering into a non-monogamous relationship for the first time, like a newer— we were non-monogamous, but he was like for the first time really starting to date someone in addition to me. And my brain went to, oh gosh, he's new at this. What if he decides that he actually just wants to be monogamous? With that person and leaves me. And it was kind of that ambiguous, like, is he going to get cowboyed over to this new person? Is he not going to be able to handle being a hinge, for example, and just all of the things that come with that? Is he just going to decide, actually, this is too challenging, I don't really want to do it anymore? But
Jase: that is always a fear because that does happen sometimes, or at least it has to me. Yeah,
Emily: totally. And I'm kind of shocked that the definition part usually has come pretty quickly in the relationships that I've had. Probably too quickly at times.
Jase: I was going to say, yeah, you maybe you err on the other side of, yeah, well, locking it down and defining it real quick.
Emily: And the people that I've been with have generally been okay with that. But non-monogamy has also allowed for a little bit more ambiguity and the question of like, well, we're just kind of having fun and enjoying each other and dating, and we don't necessarily need to put a label on it. And I appreciate that about non-monogamy a lot. But who knows, maybe in another life that I would have been super overwhelmed by the ambiguity of relationships in general. That just isn't one of the things that I tend to be that worried about.
Dedeker: Well, that's so interesting because, you know, my social media algorithms have picked up that like I've been dating newly, like since the beginning of the year, and so I'm getting all this like mostly terrible Instagram dating advice, of course, that's mostly aimed at monogamous-leaning women, right? So not really relevant for me. But that specific phrase, Emily, of like, let's not rush to label something, let's see where it goes— like, that's so often cited as like a red flag in a man if he says that to you.
Emily: But the thing is, I'm older and wiser now, so been there, done that. And now I'm just like, let's just see what happens, because
Dedeker: we'll
Emily: I don't want to put any label on it. Yeah,
Dedeker: yeah. Well, sometimes I think in certain people, in certain situations, yeah, it could be a red flag if you're like, I know very specifically what I want. And so then to date someone who doesn't want to have those conversations maybe could be uncomfortable. I guess it depends. Again, if you're 2 days in and being like, what's this going to be? And someone's like, whoa, whoa, whoa,
Jase: come on,
Dedeker: give it a minute.
Emily: Yeah.
Dedeker: Okay, so I think that in the course of Dating and creating relationships, we have a lot of opportunities for ambiguity, right? Everything from, if I met this person on an app, it's ambiguous. How's it gonna be when we meet in real life? Are they gonna ghost me before that? Are they gonna bail on me? You know, all the bad habits that are like so common in online dating right now. To, are we gonna go on a second date? Are we gonna go on a third date? Should I escalate to physical intimacy with this person earlier to see what that's like? Or should I wait until later, right? To see if I'm actually into them. Like, there's so much ambiguity that can happen. And then if things are going well, what is this going to turn into? And like, I know the two of you keep citing how non-monogamy can really help to alleviate some of that pressure, and I do think that is true, that like non-monogamy creates more of a space for letting relationships develop and find their own level. And also, I think sometimes because non-monogamy does have so many options, there can still be some stress around the ambiguity of what is this going to turn into. Are you going to be a comet partner? Are you gonna be friends with benefits? Are we gonna start out hot and heavy and think it's gonna be a really emotionally entangled relationship, but then it's not going to work out so good, you know?
Jase: Yeah, I mean, the ambiguity of you don't know how your relationship's going to go, right? You don't know how compatible you're going to be. You don't know how long the sparkiness of it's going to last. Like, all of that is still there no matter what shape the relationship takes, right?
Dedeker: Yeah. And I think that there's situations like Well, first of all, just based on the fact that so many of us are oriented towards not necessarily using the Relationship Escalator to define our relationships, but that can mean there's no built-in, like, next milestone to signal to you where things stand or where we might be headed. I find that also sometimes when people are dating and maybe stepping into somebody else's dating landscape, right, so as in dating someone who already has existing partners, there can be a question of Where am I gonna fit in? Am I ever gonna be a priority? Like, how does my relationship compare to this other relationship over here, right? And then also, I think, Emily, you talked about the whole NRE factor, where there can be these layers of self-consciousness. And I've definitely had that anxiety many, many times before when dating someone who is newer, right? Someone where I have not experienced how are they in NRE, how are they when they're dating other people. And that's a big
Jase: Very true.
Dedeker: Unknown. Yes. Of like, are they going to do what some people do, which is like go off the freaking rails and like destroy everything? Are they going to be cool?
Jase: Right, right.
Emily: Yeah. I wanted to just briefly touch on that relationship milestone thing as well, because even in non-monogamy, I think sometimes the question of what is somebody's relationship milestone difference from like my relationship milestone hopes, I guess.
Dedeker: Yeah, that the pace discrepancy thing.
Emily: Correct. So maybe you feel like, okay, like I could really see myself eventually moving in with this person or like having them be more of a nesting partner. And that person is like, you know, I would really rather live alone forever. Maybe I would rather be Solo Poly, things like that. So there still are some sort of potential discrepancies, even if you have been with someone for a long period of time. Those types of milestones may be very different for each of you, and just what it is that you want in your relationships might be really different, and that can feel challenging.
Dedeker: Yeah. So I want to talk about what are the habits, what are the behaviors that come up when we're sitting in this uncertainty. One that did make it to my list was, you know, forcing a definition conversation too early just for the sake of ending the discomfort,
Jase: right? Yeah,
Dedeker: yeah, that's one. So like, what else— what sins have y'all committed?
Jase: One that I've definitely done and have seen happen a lot is the kind of assuming because it's not defined that nothing is defined, and then realizing later, oh no, that person actually had assumed you were monogamous or had assumed that you had a certain level of communication that you expected with each other about New Relationships or something like that. I've definitely seen and done variations on that one.
Emily: I mean, I was gonna say like declaring feelings a little bit too early in the midst of NRE, especially to kind of like—
Dedeker: so that's an Emily move.
Emily: Yeah, maybe like move the barometer, like see like does this person care about me as much as I care about them sort of question. And yeah, not letting things like organically play out and go past the NRE stage to really see, like, is it just the hormones talking, or am I actually truly in love with this person, for instance?
Dedeker: Yeah, I think that we can see a lot of just our old favorites, right? I would put these under the category of obsessive information seeking. So that could be like checking read receipts, checking somebody's social media, checking somebody's dating profile status. I know a lot of people who do that. I have definitely done that in the past, you know, drafting and redrafting messages, maybe obsessing over like how you communicate to somebody, what you communicate to somebody specifically. I think that the opposite of that, like escalating to talking about feelings or forcing a definition conversation too soon, the opposite can also happen of pulling away, withdrawing, or even ending things preemptively in order to avoid the discomfort.
Jase: Protect yourself because you're like, oh, I'm not sure it's going to go where I want it to. So yeah, that's a good point.
Emily: Also, like, and I've done this with the two of you, asking your friends, what do you think this means? Who do you think?
Dedeker: Yes, that's on my list.
Emily: What's going on there?
Dedeker: Well, now it's like asking AI, what do you think this means?
Jase: Oh my gosh, sure. No, thank you.
Emily: No, thank you. But yeah, definitely just kind of obsessively speaking to your friends about it, about anything that's happening in the relationship. What do they think about this? Can you believe he did that? Blah, blah, blah.
Dedeker: Yes.
Jase: Right.
Dedeker: What is top of mind for me right now is the film Sense and Sensibility because there's the remake that came out. And so our friends over— The Love Factually podcast have been covering the '90s version of the film, and they talk about how, first of all, if you haven't seen the film or you're not familiar with the story, basically there is like an 1800s version of ghosting that happens. You know, a woman is in early courtship with a man. It's looking like it's going well. Yes, with Willoughby, Marianne and Willoughby. It seems he's handsome, he's charming with her family. You know, it seems like it's headed towards a marriage proposal, seems like it's all great, and then all of a sudden he disappears, goes to London. Doesn't communicate with her. And what you see Marianne do is literally like what I think any of us would do, but the 1800s version, right? Which is she's obsessive. She's again talking to her sisters and her friends like, what does this mean? What do you think? She sends constant notes to him. And of course she can't text him, right? So it's just like bothering the servants in the middle of the night to like constantly keep trying to reach out to him. So, but like, again, there's a modern day version of this, which is the information seeking, which is, could be double texting. Good God, maybe even triple texting. Right? If you're in a situation where either someone that you're in a relationship with starts behaving erratically and introduces that uncertainty, or if they do ghost you, that there's definitely psychological toll to this.
Jase: For sure, for sure. Yeah,
Dedeker: yeah,
Jase: yeah.
Dedeker: And speaking of that, I want to talk about basically what it can cost us when we don't have a healthy relationship or healthy coping skills for dealing with uncertainty. So this first study It's a 2025 study by Howell and Sweeny called Information Management Behavior During Stressful Waiting Periods. And I'm not going to go too much into the details because this is one of those studies where you're like, yeah, well, duh. Okay. And basically, you know, they were looking at law graduates across the 17 weeks that it takes between taking the California Bar Exam and receiving results.
Emily: 17 weeks? Yeah, that's not enough.
Jase: Yeah, but I can definitely relate to experiences of that where you take some exam or you apply for something and that is gonna be this long wait for it. Even worse if you don't know how long the wait is. You just— it might be long, maybe it's not, I don't know. Ugh, that's the worst. Okay.
Emily: Yeah.
Dedeker: And basically, they find that the people who reported more worry and more anxiety during the waiting period also reported more information seeking. However, the information seeking wasn't necessarily helpful to them, right? The information seeking didn't necessarily soothe the worrying and anxiety, as you might expect.
Jase: Right, right.
Dedeker: Yeah,
Jase: because you're seeking information that can't be gotten. Yeah, basically found, right?
Dedeker: There's only so much that you can find, right? Like, maybe you can find— you can ask the internet, right? Like, how long does it take to get my exam results? Okay, 17 weeks. Great. That doesn't help necessarily, right? It may soothe you for a little bit, but then you still have to wait the freaking 17 weeks. And this makes sense. So these same authors published a study in 2015 called "Is Waiting Really the Hardest Part?" Comparing the emotional experiences of awaiting and receiving bad news. This is another one that really tracks with common sense, and it suggests that if you aren't sure what kind of news you're gonna receive, that's more anxiety-provoking than when you get the bad news that you feared.
Jase: Yes, 100%. Yeah, I was gonna say I was gonna be surprised if it was any other result, but definitely the waiting for maybe bad news. Feels worse than getting bad news, in my experience at least.
Emily: Not that either is great, but— Yeah.
Emily: And why do you think that is? Is it just because it's that prolonged period of time that it's almost like you're continuing to sort of put your body and your mind in the state of potentially receiving that bad news, like, for a prolonged period of time, rather than just being like, "It is what it is," and being like, "Okay, I'll deal with it then."
Dedeker: I would like to answer your question in the form of an Emily Dickinson poem, if I may.
Emily: Please, by all means.
Dedeker: While we were fearing it, it came, but came with less of fear because that fearing it so long had almost made it dear. There is a fitting a dismay, a fitting a despair. 'Tis harder knowing it is due than knowing it is here. The trying on the utmost, the morning it is new, is terribler than wearing it a whole existence through. So, you know, those researchers just should have talked to ol' Emily back in the day. She had this figured out already. She knew. She had it figured out. The uncertainty.
Emily: Yeah.
Dedeker: It is the uncertainty. We have— I think our nervous systems and brains have a fundamental aversion to uncertainty. Certainty for so long has meant survival, even if certainty meant something bad, but at least then we could orient around it and, like, lay out the chessboard, right, of our strategies than when we aren't sure.
Jase: And if you are dreading maybe getting bad news, there's like, you're doing this process of trying to pre-process your grief or coping or whatever about it, but you can't complete that because it might not be true. So then you kind of have to be like, "Well, but maybe that's not gonna happen, so I shouldn't go too far there." Versus when you get the bad news—
Emily: There's like a closure element.
Jase: Well, just that you can start the process then of actually dealing with it, of— Yeah. You know, going through your stages of grief, or however you're going to need to process that. And when you have all this pre-worrying time, it's like you can't really get very far in that cycle because you don't have the information you need. And I could— I wonder if there might even be a version of that on the, like, positive side too. I guess I can relate to that some recently with, like, applying for Japanese visas and things like that, where it's like I want to start planning my life and figuring out the things I need to do to support this. Yes. But I don't yet know if I'm going to get the good thing either, right? That both the good and the bad, it's like, I just want to know, I just want to start figuring out whatever it is, my packing list or my finances or whatever. And I can't know that. And it's frustrating.
Emily: Gosh. Yeah.
Dedeker: Well, we're going to shift and talk about what the research says about relationships, specifically about what are the sources of uncertainty within relationships, and also when in the arc of a relationship we tend to get hit the hardest with uncertainty. But first, we should take a break.
Jase: We're going to take a quick moment to talk about our sponsors for this episode. Please do give them a listen. We love our sponsors for supporting this show and letting us do this for free for all of you every week. And of course, if you would rather join our community and support us directly, you can go to multiamory.com/join We have an awesome community there that you can get access to, as well as bonuses like ad-free episodes and things like that. And it's available on a sliding scale so you can support us more or less depending on what works for you and your budget.
Dedeker: Okay, so we're going to dive into a research study published in 1999 by Knobloch and Solomon titled Measuring the Sources and Content of Relational Uncertainty. This was published in the journal Communication Studies. So these authors were trying to figure out what exactly is the source of uncertainty. Where does the uncertainty come from? What is it about in dating relationships? So basically they had people rate a list of items that kind of followed the stem, how certain are you about... on a 6-point scale. So questions like, how certain are you about your goals for this relationship? Or how certain are you about your partner's goals? For this relationship. They found that there's 3 primary sources when it comes to self and partner uncertainty. So as in, there can be uncertainty about how much you yourself want the relationship, or how much your partner wants the relationship, right? So one is wanting— how much do I want it? How much do they want it? And that's uncertain. How do you evaluate the relationship, and how does your partner evaluate the relationship? In this one, anecdotally, I find can follow people through long-term relationships, not just in the early dating phase of if we feel like there's a mismatch between like, I'm really enjoying this relationship and maybe my partner is not. That can be a stressful source of uncertainty and ambiguity. And uncertainty from what do you want it to become, or what does your partner want the relationship to become.
Jase: Interesting. So that's separate from do you want it or not, but also what do you want it to become.
Dedeker: Yeah, do you want it Do you like it? Where are we headed?
Emily: Yeah.
Jase: Okay, interesting. So they found that those three came up as like the primary categories and then tried to measure them separately.
Dedeker: Yeah, basically. Yeah. Now they also looked at— and this distinction is a little bit confusing because they distinguished those ones I just talked about as like self and partner uncertainty, but then they also found this distinct category of relationship uncertainty that does have some overlap And so there, not only were people uncertain about, are feelings mutual? How's the relationship currently defined? What's going to be the future of this relationship? But also, what are the norms for how we behave together?
Jase: Interesting. Yes. I mean, that's always the complaint we make about traditional, like, default monogamy, is that everyone thinks they understand how it's supposed to go, but no one actually agrees on how it's supposed to go.
Dedeker: Yes.
Emily: Yeah, I guess. Can you give us an example of what that means? Like, girlfriend-boyfriend or very close friends? Or like, what do you mean by how we're supposed to act when we're together?
Dedeker: So based on the scale list that they were having people fill out, there were questions like, how certain are you about what your partner can or cannot say to you in this relationship? How certain are you about the boundaries for appropriate or inappropriate behavior in the relationship? How certain are you about how your partner can or cannot behave around you? So yeah, I think it is kind of like what Jase is saying is a lot of the stuff that sometimes when you're in a little bit more of a default monogamy mindset, there can be these assumptions that can get you into trouble when your partner's assumptions are different about what the norms are. And you can still get into trouble in non-monogamy too. I find that like people can still bring in assumptions about like, oh, well, like this is how I practice non-monogamy with all my partners. And so of course anyone I date is going to practice it in the same exact way, or we're going to communicate in the same exact way, or like this kind of agreement is okay and this one is not.
Emily: Yeah, that makes sense. I think that that's just another great case for please be explicit at the beginning of your relationships, just about, yeah, what, what are some expectations there around even like, I'm going to introduce you to my parents, here's some stuff that you need to know, etc. They really hate seeing PDA, for instance, so please maybe don't make out with me while we're with them.
Jase: Those are good ones actually, like the PDA and how you are in different social settings can also change because not just about what's our relationship like right now, but in certain situations where maybe we're all up on each other when we're hanging out with our Polycule, but sure, when my friend from work shows up to hang out or something like that.
Emily: These are certain topics that are maybe off limits, etc.
Jase: Yeah.
Dedeker: Now what's really interesting is, so there's this research study I found. This is also from Knobloch. This was published in 2007. This is called Perceptions of Turmoil Within Courtship. Associations with Intimacy, Relational Uncertainty, and Interference from Partners. This is published in the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships. This study found that there's basically like a particular time period in the relationship where you're most likely to experience turmoil because of uncertainty, and it's not the earliest stage of relationship. Actually, they point to more like when you feel like you've reached moderate levels of intimacy with someone, so where you no longer feel like it's casual but you don't yet feel like it's super serious and you're super close to them, that's when you're most likely to feel stressed out, turmoil, worried that the relationship's overwhelming or stressful to you because of uncertainty. So like, I take this to mean that like there's sort of that like transitional liminal space in relationship where we're getting close to each other but we're not like super entwined lifelong partners yet, but we also aren't on our first 1, 2, 3 dates or whatever. Yeah, where there's like this peak uncertainty and peak negative feelings from the uncertainty.
Jase: That makes sense. And I feel like that kind of tracks with that 3-month-ish mark that I mentioned in that relationship I started with, was it was hitting that like the dating and all the early stuff's been great, but we haven't settled into knowing where we stand.
Emily: So maybe this is not a relevant question, but I have found in my life that some relationships are like, they're fun, they're okay, they're— we're enjoying each other. But that really intense NRE that tends to happen with maybe longer-term relationships or relationships that end up having more of a staying power or an intensity in your life, Like sometimes I have had relationships where that ambiguity starts to creep in around the 3-month period and then yeah, it's really like I could go either way. I could stay with this person or not. I could like continue this on to see how it goes or not. But that often, I don't know, NRE sometimes like for me at least in my life, it has created this hope and want to like define things more explicitly. And that sort of happens like simultaneously, I've found, with the other person.
Dedeker: Yes. Yeah, I'm gonna cite— yeah, I'm gonna cite our friends on Love Factually again in their coverage of Sense and Sensibility, because they talked about how even if you are not someone who trends toward attachment anxiety, right, so even if you don't feel like you have a default anxious attachment, when you are in NRE or limerence, it is very common for people to display very heavy attachment anxiety behaviors because of that. Because, and they say it's not necessarily unhealthy, it's just an indicator that like now you have connected to someone long enough that your attachment system is coming online, and that means the stakes are increasing, and that means you go a little crazy.
Emily: Yeah,
Jase: sure,
Emily: fair enough. Yeah,
Dedeker: I did want to say what was interesting about this particular study— I know y'all have been talking about 3 months or whatever they found that this didn't necessarily match to a particular timeline. It's very subjective on like when you feel like you've reached moderate intimacy with someone. So in one relationship, that could be 6 months into an undefined connection, or maybe you're 3 weeks in and it's been really intense and you feel like you've gotten really close. It's really subjective about when you feel like you've kind of crossed that line. And I think it probably does match up to like when your attachment system comes online, when stakes start to enter into the game.
Jase: Yeah, it's interesting though, like what you were saying, Emily, about the NRE being stronger in relationships that last longer for you. And I feel like, yeah, it's often the other way around, that a lot of the ones that have had really strongest NRE burn out faster, and that the ones that had like a slower on-ramp— and that's not exclusively true, right? There's definitely exceptions to that, but It's just interesting that I feel like often the NRE, at least in my experience, is what makes it more likely that there's a misalignment, like one person's hitting that NRE a lot harder than the other. And so it's kind of this like, whoa, record scratch, like we're not aligned here. And it kind of derails and then can fall apart.
Dedeker: Interesting.
Emily: I think that can happen.
Jase: Versus a slower ramp.
Emily: That's happened maybe one time in my life that I can really recall. And that's— I've talked about this dude, that college dude that was the one that got away.
Jase: Oh, right, right, right.
Emily: Yeah, yeah. I was clearly really into him and he was like, eh. But everyone else, pretty much, I feel like they've lined up quite a bit. And it ended up being a fairly long relationship for me.
Dedeker: I'm going to talk about that in a second. I just want to share one last thing from this study, which is— so you'll notice the study title mentioned interference from partners.
Jase: Oh, right.
Dedeker: And What that actually refers to is they find that when you're reaching this like middle stage of moderate intimacy, that also tends to line up with the time when like your actual lives start to bump into each other, like your schedules, your routines, your plans. I think in non-monogamy, like bumping into the reality of what are your obligations to your other partners, or how do you approach dating, or what is it that you're looking for, right? And the authors point to that as like, oh, that could also be part of what explains the spike in uncertainty, is like This is no longer just like fun casual dating, getting to know each other. Now it's like, how are the puzzle pieces of our lives actually going to fit together?
Emily: Fair.
Dedeker: Yeah. Okay, now for your story about the college guy.
Emily: Oh,
Dedeker: I don't know if— I don't know if this is relevant. I don't know if it's relevant. I just want to share this one. So this is from Whitchurch, Wilson, and Gilbert, published in 2011, titled He Loves Me, He Loves Me Not: Uncertainty Can Increase Romantic Attraction. This was published in the journal Psychological Science. Now, some of this might be a little sketch as far as their methods, but I just wanna—
Jase: Okay. Okay.
Dedeker: Present it to you with a grain of salt. So they had 47 female undergraduates viewing the Facebook profiles. This was 2011. So they were viewing the Facebook profiles of men who had supposedly already viewed their Facebook profiles of look, the participants were told these men have looked at your Facebook profiles.
Jase: Okay.
Dedeker: And they were told either these men— and I think it was different with each man that they showed them— they were told either that this man likes you a lot, or this man likes you just an average amount, or we're not sure whether he likes you a lot or just an average amount.
Jase: He's just not into you. Yeah.
Dedeker: No, just we're not sure. Okay, we're just— we don't know.
Jase: I see. Okay, so he likes you a lot, he likes you a normal amount, Whatever.
Dedeker: Or we're not sure.
Jase: Or we're not sure. Okay.
Dedeker: Yes.
Jase: Okay.
Dedeker: So the participants that were told about the person that was uncertain, where it was uncertain which one it was, they thought about that person the most and then also reported greater attraction to that person as well.
Jase: Yeah.
Dedeker: Now, again, small sample. It's college students.
Emily: Interesting.
Dedeker: Yeah. It's based on looking at Facebook profiles, right? So who knows? But I do think I see some anecdotal evidence for this tracking sometimes.
Jase: It feels true.
Dedeker: It feels true. Correct.
Emily: It's like you want what you can't have kind of thing. Yeah. Well, yeah.
Jase: It's the whole thing of like, yeah, you really hate your job and then they fire you. You're like, what? You can't fire me. Like, it's that kind of a thing.
Dedeker: Now, I mean, there are other research studies. I didn't pull them for this one, but there are other research studies that do support that. Like, when we do know someone likes us, that greatly increases the chances that we're gonna like them back as well.
Jase: Right. So, okay.
Dedeker: That is a factor. But it does seem there is some, maybe something here in our psychology about being uncertain that like, mm-hmm. And I don't know if it actually is attraction or if it's just to give something for your brain to chew on, and then we interpret that as attraction or preoccupation with a person.
Jase: Yeah, I wonder in this study, I'm not sure if you know, but was it with the idea that then you might be able to talk to this person, or was it a little more in the abstract of like, they looked at your profile, they liked you, but there isn't really a possibility of this going somewhere, which might make those questionable ones more interesting, whereas in a real-life scenario, maybe the one that you know likes you could get more of your thoughts. You're like, oh hey,
Dedeker: like, if you think that there's a real life chance— that I'm not sure. Yeah, it it was pretty limited in scope.
Jase: Yeah.
Dedeker: So yeah, I know that that is a good question to ask. That could change things. In the last act of this episode, we're going to talk about how the hell do we deal with all of this without losing our freaking minds. But first, let's take a break.
Jase: And with that, please do take a moment to check out our sponsors. We try to have fun reading these ads for you, and we pick advertisers that we like. We actually turn down a lot of advertising opportunities, so we do really appreciate the sponsors we have on this show because they're the ones who let us do this show for free every week for all of you. And of course, a huge part of keeping this show going is our amazing community that supports us directly. If you would like to become part of that community because this show is meaningful to you, go to multiamory.com/join. We would love to have you as part of that and give you some fun gifts and access to the community as a thank you.
Dedeker: Uh, how do we cope with this? How do we deal with this? Like, we really do bump up against some of the existential stuff here of just how do we deal with uncertainty in life? How do we deal with uncertainty in relationships? And I think especially as non-monogamous people, where I think we get presented with relationship uncertainty Maybe all the time.
Dedeker: Often. All the time, right? Like, because you are accepting something like, yeah, like my partner's gonna date someone else and I have no idea how that's gonna go, and I just have to like take a leap of faith and deal with the uncertainty of that.
Emily: There's just a lot more opportunity for loss of control. Like, you can't— yeah, you're not controlling your partner's dating life. They have a separate dating life from you, and that can feel a little scary sometimes.
Dedeker: Yes,
Jase: I guess I tend to always come back to the argument that I actually think that in real life— in reality, I should say, in reality— Polyamory and non-monogamy is just as secure, or possibly even more so, than monogamy that people do. But
Emily: it does not feel that way.
Jase: Exactly. It's this illusion. We have a lot more opportunities for illusion of security in traditional monogamy.
Dedeker: That's true. That's true. So I tried, of course, to find what the research says, and mostly I think what makes this tricky is that a lot of the things that the research finds are correlational. So for instance, I found this research study from Sweeny and Howell published in 2017 called Bracing Later and Coping Better: Benefits of Mindfulness During a Stressful Waiting Period. This was published in Personality and Social Psychology Bulletin. So again, they were looking at law graduates waiting for their bar exam results. It's a juicy population.
Jase: Yeah, yeah,
Dedeker: to study. So they had two groups, right? There was a control group and then there was one group where they were assigned to practice mindfulness meditation. And they found that the participants that did better with the mindfulness meditation, they would report sort of like the anxiety and the bracing behaviors and feelings later on in the wait, as opposed to the control group that tended to report it the whole time.
Jase: How interesting.
Dedeker: Yeah.
Jase: So it just kind of like delayed how significantly that oh gosh, I can't stand it.
Dedeker: Yes. Yeah, they also felt like they were coping better with the wait.
Emily: Okay.
Dedeker: But this is correlational because they found that the people who benefited the most from the mindfulness meditation were people who are— were already coming in pretty high in their intolerance of uncertainty and also low in optimism as well, that the mindfulness meditation did help to nudge them up a little bit. As in, like,
Jase: if they were starting in the worst place possible, yeah, it did help a lot. I mean, that's, that's still meaningful. That's good. I thought at first you were just saying that the people who helped the most were the ones who were high, who were already high.
Emily: Oh, I thought that—
Dedeker: I
Jase: was like, that's not—
Dedeker: That is one coping mechanism. That is one way that we deal with uncertainty is numbing out. It is.
Jase: It's not a good way. We have actually learned that in some other episodes. It's not actually a helpful way, but—
Emily: Yeah. And it's brief. It's not going to help you for a long period of time.
Dedeker: There was another study from 2019 by Sweeny, Walsh, and Rankin titled 'A Better Distraction: Exploring the Benefits of Flow During Uncertain Waiting Periods.' Same thing, frickin' law graduates.
Jase: Really?
Dedeker: Best ones to— Wow.
Jase: Okay. Everyone loves law graduates.
Dedeker: Well, actually, so this was actually 3 studies. Study 1 was law graduates waiting their bar exam results. Study 2 was doctoral-level students who were on the academic job market waiting to hear back if they were gonna get a position or not. That one was more longitudinal.
Jase: Okay.
Dedeker: And then Study 3 was undergraduates who were waiting to find out how their peers rated their physical attractiveness.
Jase: Okay. I mean, all right. I appreciate they at least went with something different for the third one.
Dedeker: Something different. Wow. Yes. Yeah. And in these groups, they were randomly assigned to play Tetris, and either they'd be playing Tetris on a slow or easing setting, so this was meant to be a more boring experience, or they were assigned to play Tetris on an extremely fast setting. This was meant to produce a feeling of frustration. Or the classic adaptive setting that matches the player's skill, which is meant to produce more of a flow state.
Emily: Hmm.
Dedeker: Now, what they found was actually the Tetris settings didn't matter at all.
Jase: Really?
Dedeker: Basically, yes. Didn't matter at all. It was just, did the participants feel like they got into flow or not?
Emily: Hmm.
Dedeker: Right? So like, some people who got into flow on the boring setting or the frustrating setting or the adaptive ones, that was the more important piece was like, do you feel like you actually got into flow?
Jase: So basically—
Jase: Maybe it depended on how skilled they were at Tetris coming in.
Dedeker: There's that too. Yeah. And so the people who did experience more flow while they were waiting reported less worry, fewer negative emotions, and more positive emotions. Again, this could be correlational. It could be like if you're already less worried, have fewer negative emotions, and feel more positive emotions, it's easier for you to get into flow because you're less distracted.
Jase: Possible. Yeah.
Dedeker: Yeah, so, so it's the kind of thing where distracting yourself can help, only if you feel like you can actually get yourself into a flow state. But also, if you're trying to get into a flow state and you find that you can't, it doesn't necessarily mean there's something wrong with you or wrong with your coping mechanisms. It may just be like, yeah, the uncertainty here is high enough, or my uncertainty intolerance is high enough that it is just making it hard for me to get into a flow state.
Jase: You know, that's interesting. It's kind of related to some totally separate research that I was doing about games and I was looking at it more from the point of view of ADHD and like how different brains want to relax. And there was this idea of basically like saturating the mental bandwidth of having some kind of game that is fast-paced enough. There's enough stuff going on that it kind of requires all of the faculties you have there. And Tetris was mentioned in some of these research studies, the Tetris effect. Of like finding a game that's the right amount of stimulation and challenge, but not so much that you're tuning out and not too many times to just sit and like stop and think. Like it has to stay pretty constant. And that by kind of saturating all of your brain's work, lets it not get distracted by other things or stress about things or get anxious about stuff. And I could see that maybe showing up here, 'cause I know for some people Tetris, gets them a lot more than others. Hmm. Right? Like, for me, Tetris doesn't really hook me, but I've had friends where it's like that their brain just clicks into Tetris.
Dedeker: I think you really gotta find what the thing is because I think that in this day and age, like, I don't know if you're waiting for someone to text you back, you think like, okay, whatever, I'll distract myself. Like, I'll scroll on social media or whatever. And like, it doesn't actually produce a flow state.
Jase: No, no, no.
Dedeker: It's not really a great one. Right? Like, and this is gonna be so subjective and so individual. Like, you gotta find what is it. For some people it could be Tetris or some very intense video game like that, or it could be like, I hang out with my best friend for 6 hours, right?
Jase: My friend who's the one who has like the nonstop jokes or the deep conversations or something, right? Yeah.
Dedeker: And they're the one that actually helps me stay present and I'm not, I don't have that impulse to check my phone, right? That's usually more what it is for me is like if I'm really socially engaged with someone that I really care about and love, that's what helps me get into that very hyper-present flow state.
Emily: Various times in relationships where I'm wondering like, where do I stand or what am I doing or I'm, you know, maybe a little angry about something, I'll write about it. I'll maybe like act as though I'm writing a letter to that person or just writing about the incident in general or the thing that I'm uncertain about. And I think that that helps a little bit, at least for me, just kind of getting it outside of my head and onto paper so that it's not so stuck inwardly.
Jase: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. I definitely find writing something down helps. But I kind of like the idea of combining those of finding something that gets you in flow state so you can write it down. So it's like, okay, it's there. I've put it down somewhere so I don't have to keep holding it in my head and then try to find something. Like Dedeker said, it can be individual for you, whatever that is. If it's like a certain type of crafting or like project that you like, if it's a game, if it's maybe a physical activity, but something that like requires enough of your focus that you can't really think about other stuff as much.
Dedeker: There's another maybe smaller sort of silly study that I want to share with you. So this is also from Sweeny, Andrews, and Rankin. This was published in 2020. This is called awe-full uncertainty, as in A-W-E-full uncertainty, easing discomfort during waiting periods. This is published in the Journal of Positive Psychology. So these were two studies, one of them in which participants took an intelligence test and then were waiting for their feedback. And then another study where participants had an unscripted 5-minute conversation in groups of 3, and then they were waiting to learn how the others rated them. So in other words, like kind of social evaluation.
Jase: Yes. But so like 2 different ways of being evaluated, either from a test or just from social interaction.
Dedeker: While they were waiting, the participants were randomly assigned to watch a video, a 4.5-minute video. And so they were either assigned a video that was meant to produce feelings of awe, And usually that was like high-definition, like, nature footage of Earth. I think David Attenborough.
Jase: They just stuck in the— yeah, the Blu-ray of Planet Earth, and they're just like, here you go.
Dedeker: Yeah, I think it was that, right?
Jase: Sure.
Dedeker: They had what they called their positive control video, which was cute animal couples, quote unquote, was directly how they described the video. It was meant to create, like, positive feelings but not necessarily feelings of awe. Like, feelings of awe, but not like, awe.
Jase: Wow. Okay, wow. We're really getting deep into awe.
Dedeker: Uh-huh. And then they had what they call a neutral control video. I would argue with them about whether or not this is a neutral control video, but basically a clip from How It's Made about manufacturing padlocks. If anyone has been in our house with me and Jase and, we've gotten stoned on the couch watching manufacturing YouTube. That produces some freaking awe, man.
Jase: Yeah.
Dedeker: And positive feelings. So we would not be very neutral if that was the video that we had to watch.
Jase: Yeah. If I had to choose between those videos, I would choose that one. We'll pick the manufacturing videos, all sorts of random stuff.
Dedeker: Anyway, they found that the videos actually, the effects weren't huge as far as people's worry and anxiety. They did find that like the awe-producing videos boosted positive emotion and lowered anxiety compared to the neutral video, but it didn't consistently beat the cute animals. So cute animals were still up there.
Jase: If I was the professor sort of supervising this research, I might have told them to spend a little bit more time thinking about what neutral positive is, because I think Cute animals is gonna produce a lot of hormones and stuff that's not neutral. That's very, like—
Dedeker: No, that was positive control is what they called it.
Jase: Yeah, but it was like positive control versus their, like, positive awe. I just think it was the animals are so strong, and nature is only so strong, you know? Cute animals, though, it's just real powerful stuff.
Dedeker: So what can we do? As I was reviewing all of this research, I sort of distilled down what I think are the most actionable and helpful reminders for us. So the first one being that, like, it's good to get familiar with your uncertainty coping habits. So if that's constantly checking the phone, if it's constantly rereading messages or, like, trying to decode somebody's message, it could just be you have worry and anxiety that's looking for relief, but it may not change the outcome, right? We covered this somewhat on our Relationship OCD episode, that compulsively Googling something or compulsively talking to an LLM about something, maybe it could be helpful, but often it may just be trying to find some sort of pressure release valve for the uncertainty. And the thing is that, like, if you can go through the beginning, middle, and end of uncertainty anxiety, that shows your nervous system that ambiguity is a survivable threat. That, like, if things are ambiguous, you don't have to take action, you don't have to engage in some kind of compulsion, like Yes, it can feel uncomfortable, let's say, to be— I don't know, when you're like, I'm not sure when they're going to text me back, that can be uncomfortable, but it doesn't have to be something that we're like, I have to do something about it, I have to be compulsive, I have to be preoccupied about it. So that's just something to think about. From our Knobloch and Solomon research, it can be helpful if you know what flavor of uncertainty you might be feeling, right? Is it about, I feel uncertain about what I feel about this relationship, or is it, I feel uncertain about what they think about the future of this relationship? I feel uncertain about What's the acceptable behavior in this relationship? Those can be something that can help prompt a conversation for you. Next, you can expect the middle to bring up these uncertainty anxiety feelings. Again, as the research showed, that turmoil peaks at moderate levels of intimacy, and that's a common pattern. It's not necessarily proof that something is wrong based on the Facebook study. And again, we take it with a grain of salt. Who knows how legit it is? But I do think it may be helpful to ask yourself, like, am I feeling really attracted to this person? Am I feeling that there's chemistry, or is this just like rumination and preoccupation because there's something that's unknown? Doesn't necessarily mean you gotta throw your interest in the garbage. It could just mean, oh, before I can actually evaluate if I'm interested in this person, I need more information from them, right? Like, maybe I need to ask them where we stand or what they're interested in or have a more clear conversation.
Jase: Yeah, yeah, like try to actually get the information directly rather than through all these roundabout side channels, right, of just asking explicitly if it's appropriate. I guess I shouldn't maybe encourage that with like someone you just met to be like, tell me exactly how you feel about me and how you— how soon you want to live with me or whatever.
Emily: But have a conversation eventually.
Jase: Yes.
Dedeker: Yeah. If you're someone where you're listening to this and you identify as somebody who maybe has a high intolerance for uncertainty, I will say I do think for myself, my own meditation practice, I think is the best thing that has helped with how to sit in uncertainty, or when you're just like completely out of control, or like you can't change the outcome of something. Like, that's my coping mechanism. Doesn't have to be yours, but maybe that's something that you explore. Alternately, or additionally, it's good if you know what your flow activities are ahead of time. Like, are there things that you know do suck you in, do give you that sense of real absorption, as opposed to just the things that are distracting or that will be keeping you busy? That's really going to help you to have that to turn to in these moments of ambiguity. I want to end with maybe a philosophical note that—
Jase: already,
Dedeker: I think the thing that I've learned is that uncertainty and ambiguity is a condition of loving anybody in this life. It doesn't mean that, like, you have to tolerate, you know, someone who is being wishy-washy with you or not giving you what you want or, like, is avoiding communication. It doesn't mean you just have to deal with that. But I just don't think that there's any human relationship that we can ever have that completely scrubs away any sense of uncertainty or ambiguity. Even in a long-term relationship, it's like people change and we grow and life throws us curveballs. And so I do think that whether you're non-monogamous or monogamous in this life, ultimately we're going to have to deal with our relationship with uncertainty. And I want to quote the great Buddhist teacher Pema Chödrön, who actually— I'm going to probably going to misquote her, sorry Pema. Uh, she says something kind of like, if you want a life of certainty, you're on the wrong planet. So once we can look for other planets that are more certain, perhaps we can have a different conversation. But that's where I want to leave it today.
Jase: Wow.
Dedeker: From all of you, we want to hear from you on our Instagram stories this week. We're going to be posting a question: what helps you stay grounded when you're experiencing relationship uncertainty? So go check that out on our Instagram account. Also, the best place to share your thoughts about this episode with other listeners is in our episode discussion channel that is in our Discord server. You can also post about it in our private Facebook group. You can get access to these groups and join our exclusive community by going to multiamory.com/join. You can also share with us publicly on Instagram at Multiamory_podcast. Multiamory is created and produced by Jase Lindgren, Emily Matlack, and me, Dedeker Winston. Our production assistant is Carson Collins. Our theme song is "Forms I Know I Did" by Josh and Anand from the Fractal Cave EP. The full transcript is available on this episode's page on Multiamory.com.